
Alright Twilighters... Let's discuss.
There were quite a few things about this book that I loved, and quite a few that I hated. I'll vent my angst first so we can end on a positive note.
First of all:
RENESMEE?! What.
The.
HELL.
I could not say that name without laughing out loud. RIDICULOUS. I am, therefore, boycotting the name and will henceforth refer to her as 'Carlie'.
Secondly, I was a little weirded out by the pregnancy angle. I got used to the idea and ultimately liked the story, but I find it strange that Edward can't so much as squeeze out a tear, but he's got the fluid to impregnate a woman? Riiiiight. I'm not asking for a 'realistic
Vampire story', but a make-believe world has to be consistent. That's why we buy it.
Moving on... I almost lost all affection for Edward when he tried to whore out his wife to his rival. I can forgive him for hating his "monster" child, but volunteering Bella for conjugal visits to a man she had rejected? What a douche bag! Then Bella guesses what he did and isn't upset about it? That would be a deal breaker in a healthy relationship.
I would have liked to've seen Edward as a father. If he's capable of the kind of love he has for Bella, he should have made a ROCK STAR daddy. But his relationship with his daughter wasn't given any warmth or attention. That was a shame cuz nothing is sexier than a good dad and it might have helped me forgive his stint as a pimp. I also felt like he was just a secondary character in this book. He no longer dominated Bella's thoughts, so we didn't see or hear as much from him. Where was my Edward, the hero? I know the point was to make BELLA the hero this time, and the feminist in me rejoices at that, but I missed the old Edward.
While the JACOB section was interesting and I enjoyed being in his head, what was with the Leah thing? Why take the time to develop her character and then just leave her storyline hanging in the wind? I think maybe it was an attempted fake out for Jacob's love life so we wouldn't suspect how it was really heading (which
didn't work as we had it figured out LONG before it happened) but ultimately, most that section was a distraction from the heart of the story.
After Bella's transformation, a lot of time was spent while they basked in their happy situation. While I LOVED seeing them happy, I was a bit eager to see what was going to happen next. So I found myself getting bored with it. I would have eaten it up if she'd gone into that detail AFTER the Volturi trouble had passed. As it was, I found the pace of the last half of the book to be very irritating.
And what the HELL is with the 300 page build up to a war that never took place! And not once, but TWICE. The first being the scrimmage between the vampires and the werewolves that got dropped like a rock. After all that build up, she just spent a few paragraphs explaining that everything was OK now. I would have liked to have SEEN things resolve! And don't even GET me started on the final battle. This was how things ended with the Volturi in book 2 AND in book 3... in LIMBO. You can't finish a series in limbo!!! I wanted closure there! Those betches needed to go DOWN.
I wanted a RUMBLE! Here's how it goes in my head:
Tensions are high, the war is about to begin, the other halfling is presented to the Volturi, Aro declares peace and they try to turn tail, but Jane (who Bella has been goading with smirks) can't take it and lunges for 'Carlie' as soon as The Guard begins to retreat. Bella can't defend her without dropping her sheild and putting everyone else at risk, so Roselie (who never really redeemed herself) leaps between them and sacrifices herself to save 'Carlie'. Then the war breaks out. Emmett destroys Jane to avenge Rose, so Alec destroy Emmett *sob*, Jasper destroys Alec, Carlisle and Alice destroy Marcus, Edward and Jacob destroy Aro, and the rest go down as all the witnesses and werewolves join the Cullens. The two vampires that were there to see the Volturi fall had formed a secret alliance with Caius -the bored one- to overthrow Aro and Marcus, who had perverted their cause and become obsessed with power. They take up the Volturi's position as guardians of the Vampire world, and order is restored.
That way, we get our war and our happy ending without the feeling that no sacrifices were made. That's the other thing that left me a bit cold at the end. Everything got sewed up almost too neatly, with nothing in the end but the mere threat of opposition. After all, the joy in a happy ending is always in proportion to the threat of a sad ending. If the threat isn't big enough, the joy isn't as full. And the oppostiton in this book left me wanting.
Now, for the things I LOVED! I was thrilled that the wedding took place first thing. I felt like the wedding should have been the end of the LAST book, so I was relieved that she didn't drag that out. It also left me with no idea what was going to happen next, since we all predicted that she wouldn't get married and/or changed until the end. Lovely surprise.
I liked that Bella grew up and got over her annoying self esteem issues. I wish she would have started that growing process in Eclipse, so it wouldn't have felt quite so much like a personality transplant, but it made sense to me that she would find complete confidence and peace as a vampire. She was born to become one, and she really found herself when it happened. I LOVED reading about her first experiences as a vampire. That was the best writing in the series, I thought. I also LOVED LOVED LOVED Bella's Vampire Power! Very appropriate for her character and just generally badazz.
I loved the sexual release in this book. As a fan of sex in general, I was always a bit irritated by Edward's cold shouldering, though I understood it. I did miss elements of their prior relationship (such as all the sappy one liners that made my estrogen cup runneth over), but they had MAD chemistry. It was a natural evolution for their relationship and about bloody time. The 'sex scenes' were very tastefully done and fun to watch. (a little mormon porn?)
Jacob cracked me up. It was nice to have a bit of comic relief. I also really liked 'Carlie'. I wonder if Stephenie will write a series from her perspective? I could see her running with the storyline about the guy who is trying to breed a half vampire army. I bet the Volturi tracks that guy down, not to destroy him, but to join forces with him. Can you imagine?! The Volturi using their resources to find and kidnap human women with 'gifts' they could pass on to vampire children... CREEPY!
All in all, I loved the book, because I got the happy ending I was hoping for. But I was disappointed with the journey that got us to that ending.
What's YOU'RE break down of the book? I'm going to meet Stephenie Meyer this week! Anything you want me to ask her?